Comparison of the effect of supportive – expressive and cognitive-behavioral psychotherapy on depression and adherence to hemodialysis patients

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 PhD Student of Health Psychology, Torbat Jam Branch, Islamic Azad University, Torbat Jam, Iran.

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Health Psychology, Kashmar Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kashmar, Iran.

3 Associate Professor, Department of Chinese and Complementary Medicine, Faculty of Iranian and Complementary Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.

Abstract

Abstract
Introduction: The aim of this study was to compare the efficacy of supportive- expressive and cognitive - behavioral psychotherapy on depression and adherence to hemodialysis patients.
Materials and Methods: The study had a quasi-experimental design with pretest and post-test.A total of 45 patients undergoing hemodialysis were selected through purposive sampling and randomly allocated to the three study groups. 15 patients were treated by supportive – expressive psychotherapy, 15 patients by cognitive - behavioral psychotherapy and 15 patients were in the control group. The measurement tool was Beck Depression Inventory II and End stage renal disease adherence questionnaire (ESRD-AQ). The data were analyzed through spss-23.
Results: Results in the study of multivariate indicators and significance level of 0.001 in the group of supportive-expressive psychotherapy showed the size of short-term (pre-test-post-test) effect was 0.90 and long-term (pre-test-follow-up for 4 months) was 0.80 and in cognitive-behavioral therapy With the same significance level, the short-term effect was 0.61 and the long-term effect was 0.39, and finally, with the Benfroni test and using the average comparison profile, the short-term and long-term effect in supportive- expressive psychotherapy was higher than cognitive-behavioral therapy.
Conclusion: Supportive-expressive psychotherapy is more effective in improving the depressive symptoms of these patients than cognitive- behavioral psychotherapy, but no significant difference was found between these two types of psychotherapy for adherence.
 

Keywords

References

  1. Kaplan, H., Sadok, b. Synopsis in Psychiatry, translated by Farzin Rezaei, Tehran: Shahrab Publications; 1994: 42.(persian).
  2. Rahmanian, Q. A study of a codified home visit program on the mental health status of patients treated with hemodialysis in hospitals affiliated to Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, M.Sc. Thesis, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences. 2012:32- 48.(Persian).
  3. Hosseinzadeh, H. Examination of self-concept and depression in patients treated with hemodialysis in Mashhad, Master's thesis, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences.2003: 56-60.(Persian).
  4. Brunner and Sodarth. Kidney and Urinary Tract Nursing, translated by Pouran Sami, Tehran: Bashari Publications; 2008: 89.(persian).

5.Fitzgerald,j . Coping with chronic illness 3 rd ed.pensnsylvania, united states:f.a.davis company,2000:200-201.

  1. Brunner & Suddarth's. Kidney and Urinary Tract Nursing, translated by Marjan Seyed Mazhari, Tehran: Bashari Publications; 2008: 112.(persian).
  2. Takaki J, Yano E. Possible gender differences in the relationships of selfefficacy and the internal locus of control with compliance in hemodialysis patients. Behavioral medicine (Washington,DC).2006; 32(1):5-11.
  3. Takaki J, Nishi T, Shimoyama H, Inada T, Matsuyama N, Sasaki T, et al. Possible variances of blood urea nitrogen, serum potassium and phosphorus levels and interdialytic weight gain accounted for compliance of hemodialysis patients. Journal of Psychosomatic Research.2003; 55(6):525-9.
  4. Denhaerynck K, Manhaeve D, Dobbels F, Garzoni D, Nolte C, De Geest S. Prevalence and consequences of nonadherence to hemodialysis regimens.American journal of critical care: an official publication, American Association of Critical-Care Nurses.2007; 16(3):222-235.
  5. Gerbino G, Dimonte V, Albasi C,Lasorsa C, Vitale C, Marangella M.Adherence to therapy in patients on hemodialysis. Giornale italiano di nefrologia: organo ufficiale della Societa italiana di nefrologia.2011; 28(4):416.
  6. Khalil AA, Frazier SK, Lennie TA,Sawaya BP.Depressive Symptoms and Dietary Adherence in Patients with End‐Stage Renal Disease. Journal of renal care.2011; 37(1):30-39.

12.Vaiciuniene R, Kuzminskis V,Ziginskiene E, Skarupskiene I, Bumblyte IA. Adherence to treatment and hospitalization risk in hemodialysis patients. Journal of nephrology.2012; 25(5): 672-678.

  1. Prochaska, J. Norcross, c. Psychotherapeutic Theories, translated by Yahya Seyed Mohammadi, Tehran: Roshd Publications;2007: 145.(persian).
  2. Sookhk,F; Zolfaghari,M; Asadinoghabi,A ;Haghani,H. The effect of cognitive-behavioral interventions on Adherence to the medication regime of Hemodialysis Patients.Hayad ju.2014;3(20): 85-94.(persian).
  3. Badiee aval,M. Comparison of the effectiveness of two supportive-expressive and cognitive- behavioral psychotherapy on depression in hemodialysis patients. MA. Dissertation.torbat-e-jam:               Islamic Azad University Torbat-e- Jam branch.2015:48-54.(Persian).
  4. Beck, A.t., Brown, G., Steer, R.A. Manual for the beck depression inventory-II. San Antonio, tx:the psychological corporation;2000.
  5. Fathi Ashtiani, A;Dastani,M. Psychological Examinations.Tehran: Besat Publications.2010:336- 339.(Persian).
  6. Kim y . evangelista ls.relationship between illness perceptions, treatment adherence, and clinical outcomes in patients on maintenance hemodialysis. nephrol nurs j .2010;37(3):271-280.
  7. Kim,Y; Evangelista, LS; Phillips, LR; Pavlish, C; Kopple, JD. The End-Stage Renal Disease Adherence Questionnaire (ESRD-AQ): testing the psychometric properties in patients receiving in- center hemodialysis. Nephrology Nursing Journal. 2010; 37(4):377-393.
  8. Blind, c. Theories of counseling and psychotherapy, translated by Yahya Seyed Mohammadi, Tehran: Negin Publications; 2009: 61.(persian).

21.Winston.a, Rosenthal.r , Pinsker. H . Learning Supportive Psychotherapy:An Illustrated Guide.2010;42-48.

  1. Hadian,Z; Rafiee Vardanjani,L; Barimnejad, L. The most important causes of non-adherence in patients on dialysis. Clinical Excellence.2017; 2(5): 84-97.(Persian).
  2. Mehrotra, R;Cukor, D;Unruh, M;Rue, T;Heagerty, P;Cohen, SD;Dember, LM;Diaz-Linhart, Y; Dubovsky, A;Greene, T;Grote, N;Kutner, N;Trivedi, MH;Quinn, D;K,Ver;Halen, N;Weisbord, SD; Young, BA; Kimmel, PL;Hedayati, SS. Comparative Efficacy of Therapies for Treatment of Depression for Patients Undergoing Maintenance Hemodialysis: A Randomized Clinical Trial. Ann Intern Med. 2019 Feb 26. doi: 10.7326/M18-2229. [Epub ahead of print] PubMed PMID: 30802897.
medical journal of mashhad university of medical sciences
Volume 62, Issue 6
March and April 2020
Pages 1853-1865

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics