Comparing the effectiveness of Intensive Short-term Dynamic Psychotherapy (ISTDP) with Compassion-Focused Therapy (CFT) on Self-criticizing of postgraduate students

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 Master's degree, Department of Clinical Psychology, Faculty of Medical Sciences, Qom Branch, Islamic Azad University, Qom, Iran.

2 Department of Psychology, Gonabad Branch, Islamic Azad University, Gonabad, Iran. (Corresponding Author)

Abstract

Introduction: Although this is obvious that we can decrease self-criticizing by psychotherapy, the question is “is there any significant difference between the effectiveness of different interventions? The aim of this study was to compare effectiveness of Intensive Short-term Dynamic Psychotherapy (ISTDP) and Compassion-Focused Therapy on self-Criticizing.
Methods: The method was quasi-experimental, performed with control group and placebo group and also with follow-up measurement. From Qom post-graduate students of psychology in the academic year 2020-21, 60 students who had higher scores at The Gilbert’s Forms of Self-Criticizing and Self-Reassuring Scale (FSCRS), were randomly assigned for the intervention in four groups of 15: Compassion-Focused Therapy, Intensive Short-term Dynamic psychotherapy, placebo, and control. The FSCRS was used to measure the data and the data were statistically analyzed using SPSS 22 software by covariance test and Bonferroni post hoc test.
Results: The results of covariance test showed that there is a significant difference between groups (F = 150.11; p < 0.05). Bonferroni post hoc test showed that there was no significant difference between intensive short-term dynamic psychotherapy and Compassion-Focused Therapy in Self-Criticizing scores (MD = -2.17;  p> 0.05), although both were significantly less than placebo and control groups (p < 0.05). After 3 months, a follow-up showed that ISTDP is significantly better than Compassion-Focused Therapy in reducing self-criticism (MD= -5.96; p<0.05).
Conclusion: Both ISTDP and CFT are significantly effective for reducing self-criticizing but implementing ISTDP can be more effective in the long-term.

Keywords

References

  1. Trompetter HR, De Kleine E, Bohlmeijer ET. Why does positive mental health buffer against psychopathology? An exploratory study on self-compassion as a resilience mechanism and adaptive emotion regulation strategy. Cognitive therapy and research. 2017 Jun;41:459-68.
  2. Shahar G. Erosion: The psychopathology of self-criticism: Oxford University Press, USA; 2015.
  3. Whelton WJ, Greenberg LS. Emotion in self-criticism. Personality and individual differences. 2005;38(7):1583-95.
  4. Dinger U, Barrett MS, Zimmermann J, Schauenburg H, Wright AG, Renner F, et al. Interpersonal problems, dependency, and self‐criticism in major depressive disorder. Journal of clinical psychology. 2015;71(1):93-104.
  5. Fox KR, Ribeiro JD, Kleiman EM, Hooley JM, Nock MK, Franklin JC. Affect toward the self and self-injury stimuli as potential risk factors for nonsuicidal self-injury. Psychiatry research. 2018;260:279-85.
  6. Zuroff DC, Santor D, Mongrain M. Dependency, self-criticism, and maladjustment. Relatedness, self-definition and mental representation Essays in honour of Sidney J Blatt. 2005:75-90.
  7. Cox BJ, MacPherson PS, Enns MW, McWilliams LA. Neuroticism and self-criticism associated with posttraumatic stress disorder in a nationally representative sample. Behaviour research and therapy. 2004;42(1):105-14.
  8. Zelkowitz RL, Cole DA. Longitudinal relations of self‐criticism with disordered eating behaviors and nonsuicidal self‐ International journal of eating disorders. 2020;53(7):1097-107.
  9. Dunkley DM, Grilo CM. Self-criticism, low self-esteem, depressive symptoms, and over-evaluation of shape and weight in binge eating disorder patients. Behaviour research and therapy. 2007;45(1):139-49.
  10. Kopala-Sibley DC, Zuroff DC, Russell JJ, Moskowitz D, Paris J. Understanding heterogeneity in borderline personality disorder: differences in affective reactivity explained by the traits of dependency and self-criticism. Journal of Abnormal Psychology. 2012;121(3):680.
  11. Meares R, Gerull F, Stevenson J, Korner A. Is self disturbance the core of borderline personality disorder? An outcome study of borderline personality factors. Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry. 2011;45(3):214-22.
  12. Francis‐Raniere EL, Alloy LB, Abramson LY. Depressive personality styles and bipolar spectrum disorders: Prospective tests of the event congruency hypothesis. Bipolar Disorders. 2006;8(4):382-99.
  13. Fazaa N, Page S. Personality style and impulsivity as determinants of suicidal subgroups. Archives of Suicide Research. 2009;13(1):31-4
  14. Cox BJ, Walker JR, Enns MW, Karpinski DC. Self-criticism in generalized social phobia and response to cognitive-behavioral treatment. Behavior Therapy. 2002;33(4):479-91.
  15. Lowyck B, Luyten P, Vermote R, Verhaest Y, Vansteelandt K. Self-critical perfectionism, dependency, and symptomatic distress in patients with personality disorder during hospitalization-based psychodynamic treatment: A parallel process growth modeling approach. Personality Disorders: Theory, Research, and Treatment. 2017 Jul;8(3):268.
  16. Lambert MJ. Bergin and Garfield's handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change: John Wiley & Sons; 2013.
  17. Cuijpers P, Reijnders M, Huibers MJ. The role of common factors in psychotherapy outcomes. Annual review of clinical psychology. 2019 May 7;15:207-31.
  18. Gao S, Assink M, Cipriani A, Lin K. Associations between rejection sensitivity and mental health outcomes: A meta-analytic review. Clinical psychology review. 2017;57:59-74.
  19. Lloyd S, Schmidt U, Khondoker M, Tchanturia K. Can psychological interventions reduce perfectionism? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Behavioural and cognitive psychotherapy. 2015;43(6):705-31.
  20. Loew CA, Schauenburg H, Dinger U. Self-criticism and psychotherapy outcome: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Clinical psychology review. 2020;75:101808.
  21. Blatt SJ. Relatedness and self-definition in personality development: American Psychological Association; 2008.
  22. Leaviss J, Uttley L. Psychotherapeutic benefits of compassion-focused therapy: An early systematic review. Psychological medicine. 2015;45(5):927-45.
  23. Petrocchi N, Dentale F, Gilbert P. Self‐reassurance, not self‐esteem, serves as a buffer between self‐criticism and depressive symptoms. Psychology and Psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice. 2019;92(3):394-406.
  24. Saadati Shamir A, Mazboohi S, Marzi S. Validation of Self-Criticism-Self-reassuring Scale among Teachers. Quarterly Journal of Educational Measurement. 2018;9(34):133-47. (Persian).
  25. Gilbert P, Irons C. A pilot exploration of the use of compassionate images in a group of self‐critical people. Memory. 2004;12(4):507-16.
  26. Thompson R, Zuroff DC. The Levels of Self-Criticism Scale: Comparative self-criticism and internalized self-criticism. Personality and individual differences. 2004;36(2):419-30.
  27. Castilho P, Pinto‐Gouveia J, Duarte J. Exploring self‐criticism: Confirmatory factor analysis of the FSCRS in clinical and nonclinical samples. Clinical psychology & psychotherapy. 2015;22(2):153-64.
  28. Zarastvand A, Tizdast T, Khalatbari J, Abolghasemi S. The effectiveness of self-compassion focused therapy on marital self-regulation, marital burnout, and self-criticism in infertile women. Journal of Research in Behavioural Sciences. 2020;17(4):594-605.
  29. Driessen E, Cuijpers P, de Maat SC, Abbass AA, de Jonghe F, Dekker JJ. The efficacy of short-term psychodynamic psychotherapy for depression: a meta-analysis. Clinical psychology review. 2010;30(1):25-36.
  30. Irons C, Lad S. Using compassion focused therapy to work with shame and self-criticism in complex trauma. Australian Clinical Psychologist. 2017;3(1):1743.
  31. Gilbert P. Introducing compassion-focused therapy. Advances in psychiatric treatment. 2009;15(3):199-208.
medical journal of mashhad university of medical sciences
Volume 67, Issue 1
March and April 2024
Pages 79-90

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics